Active vs. Pasive Pickups

Mariler Ferrer

Well-known member
Nov 11, 2019
150
477
591
47
Zaragoza, Spain
Ok, I'm a total noob on gear and have no clue what the difference is between active and pasive pickups.

I'm thinking of getting a Boss WL-20 or WL-20L wireless system and I'm reading that WL-20 is for passive pickups and Wl-20L for active ones. This is driving me crazy because I don't know which kind of pickups my les Paul and my Jackson have.

And what's the difference between active and passive?

I would appreciate sooooo much some help ☺
 

Andrei Moraru

Well-known member
Nov 11, 2019
406
852
1,566
andreilucianmoraru.com
Guitar Experience (years)
10
Hm, always wanted to know the difference, thank you Mariler for reading my mind, now get out of there :LOL:.

Are active pickups like...always active? Or can you still use the pickup selector to change between them? I never had an active pickup installed on my guitars so I really don't know.

Also, in what scenario would an active pickup be more useful? My impression is that guitars that allow for lower tunings make use of active pickups, at least from what I was able to see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mariler Ferrer

Dominik Gräber

Well-known member
Nov 11, 2019
1,845
3,205
3,096
22
Saarland
www.youtube.com
Guitar Experience (years)
5
Hm, always wanted to know the difference, thank you Mariler for reading my mind, now get out of there :LOL:.

Are active pickups like...always active? Or can you still use the pickup selector to change between them? I never had an active pickup installed on my guitars so I really don't know.

Also, in what scenario would an active pickup be more useful? My impression is that guitars that allow for lower tunings make use of active pickups, at least from what I was able to see.
Active Pickups can have a Higher Output and are hotter in General. But they are Always battery powered and don't Work without one. They are pretty Common in the Metal scene. People often say they Sound cold and sterile, at least about EMGs. There is a Brand conquering the Market called fishman and their fluence Pickups are Said to be extremely good. @Ed Seith Has a pair of them.
 

Ed Seith

Moderator
Staff member
Nov 11, 2019
2,038
1,785
3,081
50
Marana, AZ USA
Guitar Experience (years)
35
Okay, so active and passive pickups. The question for the ages.

Passive pickups use magnets wrapped in wire to conduct the vibrations of the strings into electrical impulses transmitted to your amplifier. They take on the characteristics of the guitar - the wood (or combination of woods), finish, mass, etc, all affect how the pickups sound. If you take your favorite guitar - let's say my PRS with a mahogany back and maple top (like a Les Paul and a million other amazing sounding guitars) and put those pickups into an Ibanez with a basswood body, it will sound very different. Better or worse is up to the player, leading to millions of "tonewood" arguments in internet forums and after gigs.

Active pickups use something similar but technically much weaker, and have onboard electronics and an external power source (9 volt battery) to boost them. Active pickups ARE their own sound. You can take active pickups out of that PRS and mount them in a lead pipe with strings - literally - and they will sound exactly the same.

If you crave consistency, and want the same "my tone" no matter what guitar you play, actives might be for you. This is why a LOT of metal players love them. Tight, crisp, consistent workhorse pickups that, with their boost, are very high-output, smooth-sounding pickups.

If you like tonal variety from guitar to guitar, and like a little more dynamics in your playing (less compression), and a warmer overall sound, passives are your jam.

I typically do not recommend people have both, and they usually find out why if they try. Active pickups don't "breathe." They have a very tight, consistent tone to them, and you need to add "air" in the form of reverb, especially on clean tones, for them to sound good. Especially if you're used to more classic-sounding passive pickups. It's jarring switching from an active pickup guitar to a passive pickup guitar on the same rig in the same playing session. That's a huge part of why most players use either one or the other - so they don't wind up messing with half their tone every time they switch guitars.

Cut to the modern era. Fishman Fluence. These are a HYBRID. They are very much a big-magnet, wound passive pickup, but they also have the electronics to make them active. You can usually switch between active and passive with a switch or a push-pull volume or tone pot. This is what I have in my Kiesel. They're really quite good, though they do still sound a bit sterile. I find them to be an excellent compromise for the metal player who doesn't really like actives like EMGs. I find that they still play well with my stable of passive-pickup guitars. They still breathe.

Happy to answer more questions.
 

Mariler Ferrer

Well-known member
Nov 11, 2019
150
477
591
47
Zaragoza, Spain
Okay, so active and passive pickups. The question for the ages.

Passive pickups use magnets wrapped in wire to conduct the vibrations of the strings into electrical impulses transmitted to your amplifier. They take on the characteristics of the guitar - the wood (or combination of woods), finish, mass, etc, all affect how the pickups sound. If you take your favorite guitar - let's say my PRS with a mahogany back and maple top (like a Les Paul and a million other amazing sounding guitars) and put those pickups into an Ibanez with a basswood body, it will sound very different. Better or worse is up to the player, leading to millions of "tonewood" arguments in internet forums and after gigs.

Active pickups use something similar but technically much weaker, and have onboard electronics and an external power source (9 volt battery) to boost them. Active pickups ARE their own sound. You can take active pickups out of that PRS and mount them in a lead pipe with strings - literally - and they will sound exactly the same.

If you crave consistency, and want the same "my tone" no matter what guitar you play, actives might be for you. This is why a LOT of metal players love them. Tight, crisp, consistent workhorse pickups that, with their boost, are very high-output, smooth-sounding pickups.

If you like tonal variety from guitar to guitar, and like a little more dynamics in your playing (less compression), and a warmer overall sound, passives are your jam.

I typically do not recommend people have both, and they usually find out why if they try. Active pickups don't "breathe." They have a very tight, consistent tone to them, and you need to add "air" in the form of reverb, especially on clean tones, for them to sound good. Especially if you're used to more classic-sounding passive pickups. It's jarring switching from an active pickup guitar to a passive pickup guitar on the same rig in the same playing session. That's a huge part of why most players use either one or the other - so they don't wind up messing with half their tone every time they switch guitars.

Cut to the modern era. Fishman Fluence. These are a HYBRID. They are very much a big-magnet, wound passive pickup, but they also have the electronics to make them active. You can usually switch between active and passive with a switch or a push-pull volume or tone pot. This is what I have in my Kiesel. They're really quite good, though they do still sound a bit sterile. I find them to be an excellent compromise for the metal player who doesn't really like actives like EMGs. I find that they still play well with my stable of passive-pickup guitars. They still breathe.

Happy to answer more questions.
wow! this is a true masterclass 😄
When it comes to gear you are the one who has the wisdom.
Seriously, now I've got it clear about the pickups. Thank you Ed!!